top of page

Consumer Sentiment on Yellowstone Wolves

The citizens and businesses of Livingston, Paradise Valley, Gardiner and Cooke City depend upon visitors to Yellowstone National Park for their local economy (see multiple research reports by economists here). How much? Although there are many reasons to visit Yellowstone, the #1 activity according to Montana's Department of Commerce reports is "wildlife watching". Visitors spend see wolves and they spend approximately $80 million annually (based on calculation of wolf-dependent spending by visitors in 2005 by Duffield et. al, 2008, adjusted for inflation and the percent increase in visitors). Below are comments from visitors to our area on their personal viewpoint on wolves, how much they spend in the area, and thank you's to some of their favorite businesses. 

My wife and I have been 4x to YNP over the last 10 months. All trips had one purpose: see and learn about wolves. During our trip in late June 2021 we saw the Junction Butte pack with pups. I lost count of people lined up to see these wolves along Slough Creek, on Specimen Ridge and in Lamar Valley. We made another trip to YNP in early September 2021. Then as the end of the year approached we learned that members of the Junction Butte pack were killed while leaving the park; three of the pups dead. So-called hunters equipped with nite-vision goggles/scopes, thermography, lights, bait (you name it - anything appears justified just to kill wolves) are sitting just outside the park boundaries waiting for wolves (tolerant to humans). Their hate for this social and essential creature is unbridled. We returned in January /February 2022. Wolves were harder to see - further away. Should we come back to states that sanction bounty killings of an apex predator?

We spend on average $1,500/day/person - expenditures include fuel, restaurants, groceries, guides, educational classes and various merchandise. Combined we spend 15 days in the park.

Wonderland Cafe, Gallery of C.Thomas Huff

R

GERBATSCH

80007

Postal Code

Special Interests like watchable wildlife, backpacking, birdwatching, fishing and hiking should not have to be silent while ranching, hunting, trapping and agricultural businesses utilizing public lands have their way with politicians.

Return a sense of fair chase to the hunters by limiting the arsenal of weapons at their disposal to hunt wolves in and around the National Parks in MT, ID and WY.

Give agricultural interests options from Federally funded budgets paid for by ALL interests. Penalize those that refuse to follow the letter of the law, and be sure that these penalties are significant to influence future actions.

$1500 per 4-5 day stay.

Absaroka Lodge, Yellowstone Forever, Harvest Foods, High Country Motel, Xanterra, Super 8, Optic Yellowstone, numerous restarants and bars in Gardiner, Cooke City and Silvergate, MT.

D

Erbland

83833

Postal Code

I visit YNP 3-4 times a year and have been doing so since I saw my first wolf in 2006. My primary purpose is to see and learn about wolves. I make a point to support local small businesses - I start by staying at a wolf sanctuary B&B. I rent from an independent car rental agency, I shop at grocery stores in Bozeman and Livingston and Gardiner. I visit restaurants in all three of those towns, I have also stayed in SilverGate and Gardiner. I hire a guide, or take classes with Yellowstone Forever. I buy items from local businesses, including gear and jewelry. I watch these wolves, get to know their numbers, and then when I am home, I read Yellowstone Reports and follow information on social media about them. Having a quota in the areas around the park a good balance. Killing park wolves, who are are more habituated to humans because of the intensity of them being observed, is not ethical. The state is killing the goose that lays the golden egg for MT residents and businesses.

I usually spend $6,000.00-8,000.00 per visit. I stay at vacation rentals, local hotels, Chico Hot Springs. I hire guides and rent equipment. I visit restaurants and get groceries and wine. I always leave with bulging suitcases from the gifts and apparel I buy.

Stop the Car Trading Post, Optics Yellowstone, Yellowstone WolfTracker, In our Nature Guides, Yellowstone Forever, Wonderland Cafe and Lodge, Gardiner Grocery, Second Street Bistro and Gils Goods, Absaroka Lodge, Track Nature Center, Chico Hot Springs, Howlers Inn, Buns and Beds.

T

Arthur

32207

Postal Code

We are planning a summer trip to Yellowstone this summer and have put our trip on hold due to the state's war on Yellowstone wolves. Our projected budget for the 5-day trip was $3,000 for local lodging, food and recreation.

$2500-$3000 for rental car, lodging, food and entertainment

E

Corneio

84404

Postal Code

I am not against all wolf killing. There is some point beyond which wolves and humans cannot co-survive, as is the case with grizzlies. But I am very much against the killing of any wolf who manages to pass out of the boundaries of YNP. And I am willing to pay a surcharge that would offer compensation to any rancher suffering harm from wolves. Some wolf control is inevitable; what we have at the moment is too much.

I say all this as someone who for twenty years has taken at least two and often three trips through Paradise Valley (stopping almost every year at Dupuys at least twice) to Gardiner for four or five days each trip to fish (staying usually at Riverside Cottages in Gardiner and last year at VRBO offering) to fish the Lamar Valley and occasionally elsewhere.

My trips cost between two and three thousand dollars, flying into Bozeman (BZN) where I rent a car, and then stay in Gardiner, West Yellowstone, and, often, Island Park Idaho. I buy my own groceries, usually on the outskirts of Bozeman or West or, more often, in Gardiner. The booze I buy in Gardiner or West, usually. Fair amount of wine and booze. I am usually with my daughter and her husband or a fishing buddy, who is staying in a nearby resort. I take at least a thousand in cash and seldom bring much back, and that is in addition to the plane ticket, car rental, and motel.

Many, many thanks to Blue Ribbon Flies.

V

Sherwood

37923

Postal Code

Could I support reasonable hunting quotas as part of an ethical, science-based strategy to manage Montana's wolf population? Sure. Do I believe the harvest in zones 313 and 316 should be absolutely minimal to protect the wolves and the residents whose livelihoods depend on them? Absolutely. Do I condone Governor Gianforte and the Montana state legislature's efforts to use wolves as a pawn in a rancorous culture war to appease their anti-federalist grudge? Not a chance. They have the right, the choice and the votes to pass short-sighted, anti-wildlife legislation. They can tip the scales to support other industries whose revenues are dwarfed by the sums generated by non-consumptive tourism and recreation. They can choose to deliberately impoverish the kind people who have welcomed me to your state and shown me why it is proud to be known as the Last Best Place. I also have the freedom to spend my discretionary income in another place that shares my value for wildlife.

My family and I have had the distinct pleasure of visiting North Yellowstone three times. During this trio of visits to Livingston, Gardiner, Silver Gate and Cooke City we have spent a total exceeding $14,000. This total includes lodging, retail purchases, guiding services, car rental, groceries and restaurants. We had plans to return again with other members of our extended family who are intrigued by the wonders we described from previous trips. Those plans have been tabled since Montana has chosen to allow the senseless killing of over two dozen wolves that primarily reside in the park. We'd love to come back, but the state government needs to do its part to protect our reason for doing so.

I am grateful for the remarkable hospitality we have been shown by the friendly Montanans at Hillcrest Cottages, Absaroka Lodge, Alpine Motel, Log Cabin Café, Yellowstone Wolf Tracker, Wildlife Along the Rockies Photo Gallery, Yellowstone Grill, K Bar Pizza, and virtually all of the other businesses we patronized in Montana during our series of visits. We hope your governor and state legislators come to their senses because, without the opportunity to see wolves, we have no intentions to return to Gardiner, Silver Gate or Cooke City again.

M

Dahlman

53562

Postal Code

This is so disgusting I have canceled my trip to Yellowstone & surrounding areas. Why aren't ranchers doing non-lethal methods to curb depredation? Wolves have always been a keystone animal. Cattle not! So disturbing that with very little attacks on cattle, that wolf hunts are necessary to begin with. Just sick of this mentality! Time to evolve!

Probably $1000-1500 per visit.

K

Schuller

96150

Postal Code

My family and I were coming to visit Gardiner Montana in May 2022. We have decided to cancel and vacation elsewhere. My whole reason to come to the area was to visit Yellowstone and the possibility to view the wolves. With a stroke of a pen these wonderful beings are being unfairly shot and trapped and I will not spend one dime in Montana now. I can't believe the lawmakers are not listening to the people. The wolves of Yellowstone belong to all of us, what a shame and a waste.

Who knows? I am sure it would have been at least $3000.00 between gas for all the miles we would have traveled, food, drink, merchandise, and of course the lodging, car rental etc. Too bad I was looking forward to visiting.

L

Franke

10925

Postal Code

I would never..... Ever enjoy watching .trapping any animal.. I love to watch the wolves. I went from new England to Montana, wyoming, idaho I landed in Misaulia And left from Boseman.. Total miles 3,600 miles 7,000 with plane fair car rental hotels. horseback riding.. rodeo.. whitewater rafting.... Went to see Yellostone the film sight.. a chuckwagon meal.. tour of lamar valley...

We were blessed to have a guide in yellowstone for lamar valley If you can ask for GABE get him. was AWSOME He dose alot more we had the yellowstone park guide.. I think it was 6 hour. we met him at junction in Yellowstone and went to lamar valley. KNOCK YOUR SOCKS OFF

k

Ethier

01569

Postal Code

Our family visited Yellowstone in January of this year, 2022. This was a trip we had been looking forward to for months; we were especially excited to see wolves. What we'd hoped would be an joyous and inspiring trip was marred by news that broke the night we landed in Bozeman, Montana. Twenty wolves had been shot just outside of park. We were heartsick. Our time in Gardiner was over-shadowed by the horrible killings that happened near the North Entrance of the park. It was amazing to see the wildlife in Yellowstone, the hunting and trapping of wolves is a dark stain on your beautiful state. Please, protect wolves.

We signed up for wolf-watching in winter with a tour group. When planning our trip, many of the tours were already full. We were really happy to find a group with some opening left on days we could go. It was important to us to travel with a tour group who supports protecting wildlife. In the park, as we stopped at turnoffs to see wolves, there were buses and vans full of people, not only from all over the US, but from all over the world. there to see wolves. On our trip, we stayed in Bozeman, Gardiner and Cooke City. We stayed at hotels, ate at restaurants and bought gifts and souvenirs to bring home. We shared our pictures and memories of the wolves on social media and have written reviews on trip review sites.

We are grateful to all the great businesses and staff we met who also care about protecting wolves. Special thanks to the Tumbleweed Cafe and the Gardiner Market in Gardener. In Cooke City, thanks to Sinclair Service and Bear Claw Service - thank you for great food and your warm welcome.

J

Strobel

94949

Postal Code

I've been to Yellowstone National Park 5 times since 2012. We go for the wildlife. 2018 was the first time we saw wolves. We were so thrilled. Since we stay in the Park, we don't spend a lot outside the park, though we get gas and food at various places outside the park. My thoughts on Wolf Hunting and trapping is that the state governments are pandering to hate and violence.. Killing wolves is all about hate and violence. The proof is in the pictures and comments posted by hunters. The proof is in asking a wolf hater to leave the guns at home and take a camera instead. They won't. I know, I made that challenge to several. No response. Montana, Idaho ( with Idaho, you can see their mentality about wildlife with their game crossing signs) and Wyoming listen solely to money, ignoring science and the public. It is reprehensible that these three states prefer to pander to hate and violence rather than science and the public.

As mentioned above, we have always stayed in the Park, but have spent a good $120 in gas, around a $100 on restaurants and another $100 on groceries per trip outside the park. Most of our spending has been in West Yellowstone.

Really enjoy Ernie's Sandwiches.

T

Kannenberg

98277

Postal Code

My wife and I live in California. We have been visiting Montana and the Yellowstone area for over 15 years
The place and the people are wonderful. The wildlife is amazing. But the one thing that captivated us, that we see as unique, beautiful and worth returning to experience multiple times each year is the wolves.
We spends days of each visit searching for and watching the wolves. When we go home we follow their stories online
We talk to our friends and colleagues and encourage them to visit the park and see them too.

For accommodation, food, gas, trips and services we are spending over $5000 each visit. We visit two to three times each year and are planning longer stays in coming years.

We are watching the escalating cull of wolves in Montana, candidly, in horror. The disproportionate impact of the cull on the Yellowstone packs is heartbreaking. On an almost daily basis we learn of the death of a wolf we have personally watched from pup to adult over years of visits. It makes

We stay in local hotels, rent homes, rent RVs and trailers, buy gas, eat in restaurants and coffee shops, buy groceries, book hiking tours, photography tours, buy souvenirs and more. When we come home we dont forget Yellowstone. We buy from Montana and Yellowstone businesses for ourselves and for gifts for others online. We donate to organizations too. We are spending over $5000 each visit. We visit two to three times each year and are planning longer stays in coming years.

Thank you to just a few of the businesses we have bought from:
The Yellowstone Pizza Company
Outwest Apparel
Wild West Rafting
Wonderland Cafe
Charlie B’s Hardware
Iron Horse Bar and Grill
Gardiner Exxon
Tumbleweed Bookstore and Cafe
Gardiner Market
Roosevelt Hotel
Yellowstone Raft Co
Yellowstone RV Park and Campground
Yellowstone Wolf Tracker
Yellowstone Gateway Inn
Yellowstone hiking guides
Cowboys Lodge and Grill
Flying Pig Adventure Co.
Ridgeline Hotel
Local home owners via VRBO
Local RV and trailer owners via RVShare
Buffalo Field Campaign
Defenders of Wildlife

S

Hussey

92865

Postal Code

Your content has been submitted

Your content has been submitted

Your content has been submitted

Your content has been submitted

An error occurred. Try again later

Your content has been submitted

Your content has been submitted

Your content has been submitted

Your content has been submitted

SIGN-UP for News about Local Conservation Efforts
Wild Livelihoods Business Coalition 

Thanks for submitting!

  • Instagram
  • Facebook

Wild Livelihoods Business Coalition (c) 2021

"Being one with nature seems like an aspiration. It isn't, because we already are." - Doug Chadwick

bottom of page