
Consumer Sentiment on Yellowstone Wolves
The citizens and businesses of Livingston, Paradise Valley, Gardiner and Cooke City depend upon visitors to Yellowstone National Park for their local economy (see multiple research reports by economists here). How much? Although there are many reasons to visit Yellowstone, the #1 activity according to Montana's Department of Commerce reports is "wildlife watching". Visitors spend see wolves and they spend approximately $80 million annually (based on calculation of wolf-dependent spending by visitors in 2005 by Duffield et. al, 2008, adjusted for inflation and the percent increase in visitors). Below are comments from visitors to our area on their personal viewpoint on wolves, how much they spend in the area, and thank you's to some of their favorite businesses.
I come here to see wolves and grizzly bears.
$2,000
Thanks to all Wild Livelihood Businesses
R
Naughton
59027
Postal Code
What's transpired for the Gray Wolves of MT (& other predators) since Gov. Gianforte was elected & passed heinous legislation is tragic & cruel bounties, traps, snares. We must restore 1/1 quotas & buffer zones around the park, full stop. During lock down last fall we read about the first 3 female Wolves from the Junction Butte pack killed just outside of the park, we called, wrote letters to Int. Secretary Haaland repeatedly as the numbers of deaths climbed. We sent letters to commissioners but they kept units 313 & 316 open for hunting until their quota was reached ultimately killing 85 Gray Wolves (3 more than their quota).....I still can't accept that this has happened after 25 years of a tropic cascade of benefits to YNP just by the presence of Wolves. I went to school in WY & on weekends I'd drive up to YNP, to Red Lodge then to north entrance to Lamar Valley for the Wolves. I've been to YNP a bunch of times. The Yellowstone Wolves can't survive another hunting season like 2021.
I've spent thousands in years past. I've just booked my trip to Gardiner, MT for my visit to YNP specifically to visit the Wolves, Grizzlies and Bison. My lodging in 2 pro-Wolf lodges (Wonderland & Absaroka Lodge) is $1,500.00 + car rental $1,000.00 + restaurants/stuff add another $500.00 & gas will be another 500.00+ as we'll drive down to the TNP then return to YNP. I prioritize spending my $$$ at ethical and pro-Wolf businesses.
R
Hersey
91602
Postal Code
We can’t understand how the people of Montana don’t realize that the wolves are worth more alive than they are dead. Thousands upon thousands of people come each and every year to witness these majestic animals.
We travel to Gardiner twice each year, in the spring and fall to see all of the beauty and wonder that Yellowstone has to offer. We spend between $5000-7000 on each trip. This includes lodging, restaurants, groceries, gas, and merchandise from mainly the town of Gardiner. Not to mention flights and rental cars from Bozeman international airport for each trip.
We would like to thank the Big Rock Inn, Yellowstone Pizza, the Gardiner Market as well as the Conoco gas station for making our trips easier and overall bettter. We also appreciate the restaurant at the Soda Butte Lodge and the visitor center in Cooke City. Silver Gate is always a good spot to check for moose and to visit Stop the Car Trading Post. The various locations for the Yellowstone Grill throughout the park are always good for a quick bite to eat anytime of day.
J
Miksic
15227
Postal Code
Stop killing the animals that make YNP the destination that it is. People come from every state and from all over the world to see wolves. The current legislation permits setting of baits, carcasses or other attractants to lure them out of the park, at which time they're immediately shot. This is madness. The State of ID, MT and WY must implement a 10 mile hunting and trapping free buffer around YNP - otherwise, the park will be silent! We also need to advocate for ethical and regulated hunting laws for wolves. Currently, these 3 states have no restrictions on wolf hunts. They can be killed using any means possible. So called hunters attack dens and kill newborn pups. I'm a hunter but I don't support this type of madness. Most hunters are not barbaric like some of these wolf hunter. Even in MT there is a large hunter's group that has taken out billboards calling for an end to the madness.
We visit the park every 2-3 years and spend $3K to $4K on food and lodging alone.
Arrowhead Lodge, West Yellowstone.
T
Spika
84404
Postal Code
We feel very strongly that animals in the park, including wolves, bears, etc. must have protection from being shot for so called sport when they step foot outside the boundaries of the park. The States of ID, MT and WY need to implement a 10 mile no hunting or trapping buffer zone around the perimeter of the park. Currently, these states permit baiting of wolves with carcasses or other attractants immediately outside park boundaries. This is unethical and destroys the image of the majority of good people in these states. The primary attraction of YNP is it's wildlife and we travel from out of state to enjoy it, not to kill it!
We visit YNP every 2-3 years, and spend approx. $3K-$4K on food and lodging alone.
Arrowhead Lodge, West Yellowstone
T
Spika
84404
Postal Code
Wolf hunting and trapping has kept me from spending money in the area of north of Yellowstone NP. That is a loss of approximately $10,000 per year that businesses are losing out on. In addition, I am not bringing clients to the park who spend an average of $2,000 a week for fuel, lodging and meals. STOP THE WOLF HUNT and I will again support the region.
S
Zelasko
92082
Postal Code
KAREN BROWN <brown_kk@yahoo.com>
To:
Karen Brown
Mon, Mar 21 at 1:51 PM
I have been coming to Yellowstone regularly over the last 15 years. In some years twice per year. I bring friends and family almost every time to show them the amazing park and it’s Greater Ecosystem. I come for the wildlife and the scenery. At the top of my list is predators.
I am appalled by the killing of wolves in such large numbers. It is an absolute failure of the local states to protect and treasure their wildlife. The methods are heinous and harken back to the eradication perpetrated in the late 1800s. As a US Citizen I am disgusted by Montana’s treatment of the Yellowstone Ecosystem .
When I visit I spend money on everything supplies to souvenirs to cars and gas and accommodations. You can bet that I will be asking every one I consider visiting about their stand on predators. And you can bet I am going to fight for the relisting of the wolf. Those animals belong on landscape.
Several thousand per visit
K
Brown
95603
Postal Code
I took my family to visit Yellowstone National Park for the first time in October of 2021. Our first entry into the park was via Yellowstone Wolf Tracker private coach. I specifically organized our entire family trip around the goal of being able to safely and ethically view wolves in the wild. It was a magical experience, one that filled our hearts and lit a fire in us (as future full-time residents of Livingston MT) to do everything we can to protect not just the park but the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem as a whole. We support ethical hunting and restrictions based on fair chase guidelines + fact-based scientific research. The current hunting legislation, particularly for areas adjacent to YNP, is simply appalling and must be reformed or else Montana stands to lose far more than wolves.
Our expenditures for visiting the GYE in 2021 are as follows:
Car Rental: $1747.96
Lodging: Sage Lodge = $5088.76; Kimpton Armory Bozeman = $548.50
Restaurants: Chico Hot Springs = $436; Yellowstone Valley Grill = $232; Wildflour Bakery = $80.94; Emigrant General Store = $85.18; Katabatic Brewing Co = $248; Neptunes Grill Livingston = $35; Wonderland Cafe Gardiner = $43; Revelry Bozeman = $96; Bozeman Spirits = $22.50; Ross Peak Grill Bozeman = $37.10, Rockford Coffee Bozeman = $18.31
Yellowstone Wolf Tracker Guide Service = $850
Merchandise and Gifts = $670.59
GRAND TOTAL (two visits to Paradise Valley with travel through Bozeman) = $10,239.84
We absolutely adore Chico Hot Springs, Sage Lodge, Yellowstone Wolf Tracker and YNP, Wildflour Bakery, Emigrant General Store, Yellowstone Valley Grill, and Katabatic Brewing Co.
C
Vaught
92008
Postal Code
My in-laws built a house in the Paradise Valley in the early 1990s. My wife and I visit yearly to hike, fish and observe the wildlife. One of our favorite memories is seeing and hearing wolves in the Park while cross country skiing on Blacktail Plateau. Science needs to dictate how wildlife should be managed in areas where human and wildlife interactions occur. If populations need to be reduced, it should be by humane means. Leg snares are not humane and are contradictory to the concept of ethical hunting.
Our economic impact over the past 30 years in Montana is significant. We fly into and out of Bozeman, rent a car during our stay, buy groceries in Livingston, purchase non resident fishing licenses, and partake in restaurant dining and shopping in Bozeman, Livingston and Emigrant. We are not against hunting as long as quotas are being made based on sound science by Montana Fish and Wildlife Biologist. Politics and lobbying should have no influence on these decisions.
J
Jackson
32720
Postal Code
I have visited the park regularly since the early 70's. While lots of elk were pretty, it was not very dynamic. The wolf reintroduction was a game changer. To see an ecosystem restored to a more complete state has been one of the more fascinating events of my lifetime. Sadly and abruptly, the anti-wolf pogrom instituted by this Gianforte administration has changed that. No longer can we view wolves "doing their thing" within 300 yards. I am a hunter, but to view animals that aren't hunted has been a gift. I fear we've seen the best of it.
We visit 2-4 times yearly, usually during the off season. We spend a minimum of $2,000 per week between food and lodging. Three time that if during the popular times. We used to stay in Cooke City or Silvergate but no longer do after 926 was killed in Cooke City, as we don't know which businesses are "wolf-freindly" and which ones aren't. We never buy gas there. So we usually stay in Gardiner. We spend 6-8K yearly wolf-watching, but that will decrease with the sudden decrease in wolf viewing. I was there all of January into February and this has been the worst wildlife viewing I've encountered. Very disappointing and I will look to spend my money elsewhere.
Thanks so much to the Yellowstone Gateway Inn, the Super 8, and the Gardiner Market. Also the Wonderland Cafe and the pizza place that used to be next to it-we miss them, and they had good beer! We used to go to the Best Western for food and lodging but have heard various reports of their wolf-friendliness.
S
Wolff
55802
Postal Code
I have visited Yellowstone National Park 24 times from Scotland since 2009. My primary reason for visiting is to see the park wolves and I've been lucky enough to follow several packs in the Northern Range over the years - Druids, Lamar Canyons, Junction Butte, Blacktail, Mollies etc. It has greatly saddened my to follow what has been happening in Region 3 and specifically the 2 WMUs bordering Yellowstone. Wolves, who spend the majority of their lives living and hunting in the park have been lured over the invisible border and shot destroying pack dynamics and stability. Packs I have followed and wolves I pay to visit and view have been hit hard. This indiscriminate hunt has no basis in science. While I'll never understand hunting wolves I appreciate that it will happen. Consideration should be given to reinstating the quotas previously in place in the WMUs bordering YNP. I will continue to support businesses in Gardiner who stand to be impacted by the loss of park wolves.
Over the years I have taken 9 Wildlife Field Seminars with YA/YF at an average of $500 (total $4500). I've attended 10 Winter Wolf trips with a Gardiner based company at an average of $2500 (total $25,000). For the last few years I've used a Gardiner based Wildlife Guide for 9 days at a cost of $5850 and have a further 3 days booked at $2100. On top of Guided tours I spend approx $1750+ a time on lodging, $500+ on meals, drinks and groceries and $200+ on miscellaneous goods. I rent a vehicle from Bozeman at approx $1000 a time and spend money in Bozeman for lodging and meals on arrival.
Yellowstone Wildlife Guide Company. Yellowstone Wildlife Profiles. Yellowstone Wild. Yellowstone Wolf Tracker. Wonderland Cafe and Lodge. Tumbleweed. Gardiner Market.
E
Christie
AB10 1QL
Postal Code
We have been to YNP several times over the years and have seen wolves about half the time we are there. There has not been a single time we have seen wolves where one was not killed. We have pictures of them, but find out afterwards they had been shot. Not exactly the best way to keep memories of the trip.
We typically rent a cabin/house and have used guides several times.
S
Gilbert
59602
Postal Code
Your content has been submitted
Your content has been submitted
Your content has been submitted
Your content has been submitted
An error occurred. Try again later
Your content has been submitted
Your content has been submitted
Your content has been submitted
Your content has been submitted